Best authentic Italian restaurants in Mumbai 2025

Looking for the best authentic Italian restaurants in Mumbai 2025? From Fort’s Americano to Juhu’s Cecconi’s, BKC’s buzzing pizza bars, and new fine-dining darling La Panthera, here’s Paperboard’s guide to the most authentic Italian dining in the city — where to go, what to order, and why these restaurants stand out.

Americano – Among the best authentic Italian restaurants in Mumbai 2025 (Fort)

The Experience: Americano is where Mumbai’s cultural crowd gathers for soulful Italian cooking in an art-inspired space. Chef Alex Sanchez’s plates balance comfort with finesse, making it a modern icon.

What to Order: The braised mushroom pizza, fresh handmade pasta, and their cult-favourite tiramisu.

Toast Pasta Bar – Lower Parel

The Experience: Chef Devika Manjrekar’s pasta bar at Kamala Mills is cosy, chic, and intimate — the kind of spot you want to keep to yourself but can’t stop recommending.

What to Order: The seasonal truffle pasta and rotating signature specials.

Cecconi’s – One of the best authentic Italian restaurants in Mumbai 2025 with a sea view

Signature Style: Northern Italian classics meet the romance of the Arabian Sea. With breezy terraces and Juhu sunsets, Cecconi’s feels like a Milanese trattoria that wandered onto the beach.

What to Order: Seafood cicchetti, handmade pasta, and a wood-fired pizza at golden hour.

CinCin – Bandra Kurla Complex (BKC)

Paperboard Loves: Aperitivo hour done right. CinCin brings Italy’s buzzing energy to BKC, with wood-fired pizzas, hand-rolled pasta, and cocktails that make weekdays feel like weekends.

What to Order: Spaghetti cacio e pepe, margherita pizza, and a round of aperitivo cocktails.

Motodo Pizzeria – BKC

The Experience: At Jio World Drive, Motodo feels like Naples meets Milan — pizzas with blistered crusts and a bar that could hold its own in any European city.

What to Order: Panzerotti, nduja burrata pizza, and the house tiramisu.

La Panthera – A glamorous new entry in the best authentic Italian restaurants in Mumbai 2025

Signature Style: Theatrical and glamorous, La Panthera is a plush European salon where velvet curtains, dramatic cocktails, and a roaming menu make it BKC’s hottest new address.

What to Order: Morels risotto, charred octopus, 48-hour fermented pizza, and the profiterole dessert. Pair it with cocktails like Roll the Dice.

Gustoso – Kemps Corner & Khar

The Experience: Elegant yet comforting, Gustoso is Mumbai’s ode to Naples. A place for gnocchi, ravioli, and tiramisu that tastes like it’s straight out of a nonna’s kitchen.

What to Order: Potato gnocchi, bruschetta, ravioli, and their decadent tiramisu.

Romano’s – Vile Parle (JW Marriott Sahar)

Signature Style: Refined hotel dining done with warmth. Romano’s combines an open kitchen, plush interiors, and handmade pastas that feel like a welcome-home ritual after a long flight.

What to Order: Handmade pastas, risottos, and selections from their Italian wine list.

Trattoria – Cuffe Parade

The Experience: A South Bombay institution that has stood the test of time. Generations of regulars still swear by its pizzas and lasagna — and for good reason.

What to Order: Classic thin-crust pizzas, lasagna, and other hearty staples.

Celini – Santacruz

Paperboard Loves: At Grand Hyatt Mumbai, Celini is sleek and understated, letting traditional Italian recipes shine. Think polished service, authentic flavours, and timeless dishes.

What to Order: Wood-fired pizzas, risottos, and their classic tiramisu.

Botticino – Bandra Kurla Complex (BKC)

Signature Style: Refined, elegant, and quietly luxurious. Botticino at Trident BKC is the kind of restaurant made for slow dining with a bottle of Italian red.

What to Order: Osso buco, risotto, and their artisan breads.

People Also Ask (FAQs)

Q: Which are the best authentic Italian restaurants in Mumbai 2025?A: Americano (Fort), Cecconi’s (Juhu), La Panthera (BKC), Gustoso (Kemps Corner/Khar), and Toast Pasta Bar (Lower Parel) are among the top picks.

Q: Where can I get the best tiramisu in Mumbai?A: Americano, Gustoso, and Motodo Pizzeria are all celebrated for their tiramisu.

Q: Which Italian restaurant in Mumbai has the best sea view?A: Cecconi’s at Soho House in Juhu offers handmade pasta and pizzas with panoramic views of the Arabian Sea.

Q: What’s the newest Italian fine dining restaurant in Mumbai?A: La Panthera in BKC, which opened in 2024, is Mumbai’s most stylish new Italian-European destination.

Q: What’s the best Italian restaurant near Mumbai Airport?A: Romano’s at JW Marriott Sahar in Vile Parle is the top choice for travellers.

From heritage spots like Trattoria and Gustoso, to modern stars like La Panthera and Toast Pasta Bar, the city’s Italian dining scene has never been stronger. If you’re searching for the best authentic Italian restaurants in Mumbai 2025, this list is your insider’s passport to the finest pasta, pizza, and tiramisu the city has to offer.

For more such reviews, follow Paperboard Magazine.